Clark ChilsonSecrecy’s Power: Covert Shin Buddhists in Japan and Contradictions of Concealment

University of Hawaii Press, 2014

by Luke Thompson on November 11, 2014

Clark Chilson

View on Amazon

Clark Chilson’s new book, Secrecy’s Power: Covert Shin Buddhists in Japan and Contradictions of Concealment (University of Hawai’i Press, 2014) examines secret groups of Shin (i.e., True Pure Land Buddhist) practitioners from the thirteenth century onward, but focuses primarily on the past 150 years.  Although today at least thirty different lineages of secret Shin continue to operate, with a total estimated membership numbering in the tens of thousands, because they have been so successful at hiding (a technique they have perfected over a period of centuries), few scholars are even aware of their existence.  Based on extensive ethnographic fieldwork that he conducted from 1998 onward and a number of reports written by mainstream Shin monks who infiltrated these groups or researchers who befriended them, Chilson explains why certain groups concealed their doctrines and practices (and even existence) and, more importantly, reveals the long-term consequences that secrecy had on these groups.  In addition, Chilson provides an in-depth theoretical introduction, showing that scholarship on secrecy has too often conflated different types of secrecy (e.g., esotericism and social secrecy), a problem that is particularly vexing in the case of Japanese religion, in which the influence of esoteric Buddhism is so pervasive.  Rather than simply confining such theoretical concerns to the introduction and conclusion, Chilson skillfully weaves issues related to concealment into the fabric of each chapter, explaining how the case studies he presents illustrate this or that function or consequence of secrecy.

Chilson distinguishes between two types of covert Shin groups—those that went into hiding due to persecution, and those in which secrecy was an integral element from their very genesis—and outlines the similarities and differences between the two.  While much scholarship on secrecy in religion has focused on why groups have secrets in the first place (e.g., to avoid persecution) and on secrecy’s personal power (e.g., personal authority, or the power to avoid detection), Chilson draws our attention instead to how concealment influences the structure, doctrines, and practices of these groups, and to the way in which secrecy, at first a consciously wielded instrument, is eventually incorporated so thoroughly into a tradition that its power becomes structural, a force controlled by no single person but which pervades the group and becomes central to its identity.  In this way, Chilson answers the question that many readers will want to ask: why did the practice of secrecy continue in persecuted groups once the threat of persecution had subsided?

On a fascinating journey that takes us from Shinran’s thirteenth-century admonition of his eldest son for claiming to possess secret teachings, to a twenty-first-century covert Shin leader who worries about the dwindling number of adherents, we hear of secret caves in southern Kyushu used for clandestine worship, dietary proscriptions of chicken and milk, punishment of covert Shin members in northeastern Japan (ranging from promises to abandon covert Shin to crucifixion), and a covert Shin group whose members associated themselves with the Kūyadō and became ordained Tendai Buddhist priests in order to deflect suspicion.  In addition, through access to groups that few scholars have been granted, Chilson describes in detail many of the initiation rituals and teachings at the center of certain covert Shin groups, all the while addressing the ethical dilemmas that researchers studying secret groups face.  This book will be of particular interest to those researching or interested in Jōdo shin shū (Japanese True Pure Land Buddhism), secrecy in religion, secret societies, Edo-period regulation of religious groups, modern Japanese religion, and religious identity.


Paul CoppThe Body Incantatory: Spells and the Ritual Imagination in Medieval Chinese Buddhism

October 27, 2014

Paul Copp’s new book, The Body Incantatory: Spells and the Ritual Imagination in Medieval Chinese Buddhism (Columbia University Press, 2014), focuses on Chinese interpretations and uses of two written dhāraṇī during the last few centuries of the first millennium.  Based on extensive research on the material forms that these dhāraṇī took, Copp departs from a [...]

Read the full article →

Chun-fang YuPassing the Light: The Incense Light Community and Buddhist Nuns in Contemporary Taiwan

October 14, 2014

Chün-fang Yü’s new book, Passing the Light: The Incense Light Community and Buddhist Nuns in Contemporary Taiwan (University of Hawaii Press, 2013), focuses on a community of nuns in Taiwan founded in the early 1980s, and discusses the appearance and development of this community within the context of rapidly changing social and economic circumstances in Taiwan during [...]

Read the full article →

Mark EpsteinThe Trauma of Everyday Life

October 13, 2014

[Cross-posted from New Books in Psychoanalysis] Being human, much of our energy goes into resisting the basic mess of life, but messy it is nonetheless. The trick (as psychoanalysts know) is to embrace it all anyway.  “Trauma is an indivisible part of human existence. It takes many forms but spares no one,” so writes psychiatrist [...]

Read the full article →

James CarterHeart of Buddha, Heart of China: The Life of Tanxu, a Twentieth-Century Monk

June 11, 2014

[Cross-posted from New Books in East Asian Studies] Jay Carter’s new book follows the life of one man as a way of opening a window into the lived history of twentieth-century China. Heart of Buddha, Heart of China: The Life of Tanxu, a Twentieth-Century Monk (Oxford University Press, 2011; paperback edition 2014) is less a traditional biography than a [...]

Read the full article →

Stephen T. AsmaAgainst Fairness

May 19, 2014

[Cross-posted from New Books in Big Ideas] Modern liberalism is built on the principle of equality and its corollary, the principle of fairness (treating equals equally). But have we taken the one and the other too far? Are we deceiving ourselves about our ability to treat each others equally, that is, to be “fair?” In his provocative new book Against Fairness (University [...]

Read the full article →

Kathleen D. SinghThe Grace in Dying: A Message of Hope, Comfort and Spiritual Transformation

April 3, 2014

[Cross-posted from New Books in Spiritual Practice] The process of dying has traditionally been fraught with anguish and despair in most Western societies, where letting go of our earthly existence is the last thing most of us want to do. Backed by her many years of working with the dying, psychotherapist and longtime spiritual practitioner Kathleen [...]

Read the full article →

Jane IwamuraVirtual Orientalism: Religion and Popular Culture in the U.S.

August 22, 2013

[Cross-posted from New Books in Religion] In popular perception, a certain image arises when we imagine eastern religions. Perhaps, we envision a wise old Asian man in traditional clothing sitting in a meditative state (maybe not). But why does this image emerge? Jane Iwamura, Chair of The Department of Religious Studies at the University of the West, examines [...]

Read the full article →

Kevin Gray CarrPlotting the Prince: Shotoku Cults and the Mapping of Medieval Japanese Buddhism

February 6, 2013

[Cross-posted from New Books in East Asian Studies] Kevin Gray Carr’s beautiful new book explores the figure of Prince Shōtoku (573? – 622?) the focus of one of the most widespread visual cults in Japanese history. Introducing us to a range of stories materialized in both verbal and visual narratives, Plotting the Prince: Shotoku Cults and [...]

Read the full article →

Carl YamamotoVision and Violence: Lama Zhang and the Politics of Charisma in Twelfth-Century Tibet

October 24, 2012

[Cross-posted from New Books in East Asian Studies] Lama Zhang, the controversial central figure in Carl S. Yamamoto’s new book may or may not have participated in animal sacrifice, sneezed out a snake-like creature, and engaged in other acts of putative sorcery early in his life. What we can say about this fascinating character, however, is that [...]

Read the full article →